"Andrea Silenzi plays both host and subject, delving into strangers’ romantic entanglements and processing her own with the same warm, wry curiosity."  
                                                        — New York Times


Hillary Frank


Lindsey Kratochwill


Teddy Blanks


Andy Miccolis
Lee Rosevere
Casey Holford
Uncle Bibby
Michael Fort


Sarah Bentley, Hans Bilger, Jason Gambrell, Sam Dingman, Margaret Kelley, Ilana Millner, Mike Sacks, Faith Smith, A.C. Valdez, Mary Wilson, Ann Heppermann, Katherine Wynkoop, Laura Mayer, Andy Bowers, and everyone at Panoply.

Why Oh Why is a weekly podcast about relationships from Panoply.

In each episode, Andrea Silenzi speaks with friends, experts, and guys in bars about where love and sex meets technology. The show tells the stories about relationships by blurring the lines between memoir, documentary, and fiction.

"Andrea is drawn to the chaotic. She is drawn to the unorderednot that she doesn't have great organizational skills. But, in a dichotomy between that which is rote, and that which is unpredictable, she will always trend towards the unpredictable."
                                               — Mike Pesca, Slate's The Gist


Andrea Silenzi is an accomplished radio producer known for her innovative and personal brand of storytelling. From going on Planet Money to get dating advice from an economist, to recording her IUD insertion, the first years of Why Oh Why were full of surprising moments and conversations. When reviewed by the Guardian’s Media podcast, the show was described as an, “honest, funny and uncompromising discussion of the issues encountered by young women every day.”

Previously, Andrea was the founding producer of The Gist with Mike Pesca. In her time there, The Gist was highlighted as a Best New Podcast by iTunes, named a Webby honoree, and was twice featured on the popular public radio show This American Life. She holds the world record for most guests booked for an hour-long radio show, and that's 67.


New York Times: "In this auditory exploration of modern love, Andrea Silenzi plays both host and subject, delving into strangers’ romantic entanglements and processing her own with the same warm, wry curiosity. The show mimics dating’s emotional roller coaster, careening from the excruciating awkwardness of a real first date to the quiet heartache of Ms. Silenzi’s latest breakup."

Vulture: "Andrea Silenzi, the host and creator of this bizarre podcast, is a genius of the cringe. Her show interrogates romance and human relationships in the digital age, but it does so in a manner that defies shape and form."

Splitsider: "If fans of Andrea Silenzi’s original iteration of Why Oh Why? on WFMU had any doubts about her new revival on Panoply, they were shattered in the first few seconds of the single straight guy focus group."

Photo by Ilana Millner

"Her meticulous editing and authentic subjects resonated with a vocal base who quickly grew to trust her unconditionally because of her openness about sex and dating."
                                                     — A.V. Club